View source for WTP Readiness For CBI

This wiki page captures the the readiness of WTP projects to move from PDE to CBI builds. 

'''Instructions: ''' Find your project in the table below and mark each task and overall readiness with either a "checkmark" or "cross". The Comment column is meant to capture differences, or overall comments in each projects analysis of build artifacts. 

The Build comparison should be done using same day builds (I used 5/8 builds) [https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=420889 This bug is driving this task]

Smoketests should be done on a recent build (like 5/8) - [https://hudson.eclipse.org/webtools/job/cbi-build/ builds are located here] - I used the repository

Your vote in the below table will not trigger any immediate action. The information collected will be used for further discussions and plans on using the CBI output in the Luna aggregation builds.

 [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] = I feel comfortable moving to CBI for Luna release
 [[Image:Fail.gif]] = I don't feel comfortable moving to CBI yet - more work to be done
 [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]= Readiness status pending

{| cellpadding="5" border="3"
|-
! Project Lead 
! Build Comparison
! CBI Build Smoketest 
! Overall Readiness 
! Comments
|-
! colspan="5" | ''Common Tools''
|-
| Carl Anderson 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| 
|-
! colspan="5" | ''Dali''
|-
| Neil Hauge 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
|
|-
! colspan="5" | ''EJB Tools''
|-
| Kaloyan Raev 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| <br>
|-
! colspan="5" | ''Java EE Tools''
|-
| Chuck Bridgham 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| Other than changes in size because of jar signing...  The one major difference in CBI is the generation of xxx.userdoc.feature.source jar's - these are a waste - and should be removed (bug 434890), but doesn't prevent moving forward.
|-
! colspan="5" | ''JavaScript Development Tools''
|-
| Christopher Jaun 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| 
|-
! colspan="5" | ''JavaServer Faces''
|-
| Raghunathan Srinivasan 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| Source features (''org.eclipse.jsf.feature.source'', ''org.eclipse.jst.jsf.apache.trinidad.tagsupport.feature.source'', ''org.eclipse.jst.webpageeditor.feature.source'') contain '''build.properties''' in CBI, where they did not in legacy build.
Extra plug-in in CBI: ''org.eclipse.jst.jsf.doc.user.source''.

These should be investigated, but are not reason to prevent moving to CBI.
|-
! colspan="5" | ''Release Engineering''
|-
| Carl Anderson 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| 
|-
! colspan="5" | ''Server Tools''
|-
| Elson Yuen 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]  
| JUnit not running yet.
|-
! colspan="5" | ''Source Editing''
|-
| Nick Sandonato 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] 
| Extra plugins in CBI build (Bug 435092):
org.eclipse.jst.jsp.ui.infopop.source,
org.eclipse.wst.dtd.ui.infopop.source,
org.eclipse.wst.dtdeditor.doc.user.source,
org.eclipse.wst.html.ui.infopop.source,
org.eclipse.wst.sse.doc.user.source,
org.eclipse.wst.sse.ui.infopop.source,
org.eclipse.wst.standard.schemas.source,
org.eclipse.wst.xml.ui.infopop.source
|-
! colspan="5" | ''Web Services Tools''
|-
| Keith Chong 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] 
| 

'''Web Services and WSDL''' ( [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] , [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] , [[Image:Questionmark.gif]] )

Build comparison - TBD

Failing test: org.eclipse.wst.validation.test

Failing test: org.eclipse.wst.wsi.tests.internal.BasicProfileAnalyzerTest.testReportWriterIsClosedAfterReportIsFinished


'''JAX-WS sub-component''' ( [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] , [[Image:Checkmark.gif]] , [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  )

Extra feature included in CBI build (Bug 435094):

org.eclipse.jst.ws.jaxws_userdoc.feature.source

Other source features in CBI build contain an additional file: build.properties
org.eclipse.jst.ws.cxf.feature.source
org.eclipse.jst.ws.jaxws.dom.feature.source
org.eclipse.jst.ws.jaxws.feature.source

Differences in jars files sizes between PDE and CBI because of jar signing.

One failing test:
org.eclipse.jst.ws.jaxws.dom.runtime.tests.annotations.AnnotationFactoryTest.testRemoveAnnotationsIMethod 

Same NPE error reported in that test also thrown in these two:
org.eclipse.wst.server.ui.tests.dialog.DialogsTestCase.testDeleteServerDialog
org.eclipse.wst.common.snippets.tests.providers.TextProviderTests.testTextSnippetCreation

|}

[[Category:Eclipse_Web_Tools_Platform_Project|Eclipse_Web_Tools_Platform_Project]]