Jump to: navigation, search

Difference between revisions of "WTP Smoke Test Results R323 12162010"

(12/16)
 
(Smoke Test Promotion votes)
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Smoke Test Promotion votes ==
+
== Smoke Test Promotion votes ==
  
 
Instructions:  
 
Instructions:  
  
Use a red X (fail) icon ([[Image:Fail.gif]]) to signify that the  
+
Use a red X (fail) icon ([[Image:Fail.gif]]) to signify that the build should not be promoted, that a respin is required. In that case, please provide bug number and be sure those that need to fix something are aware of it, and can arrange for a respin. Once the issue has been fixed, and confirmed, change the red X to a green check mark with the build Id where is was verified, so those doing the promotion know its ready to go.  
build should not be promoted, that a respin is required. In that case, please  
+
provide bug number and be sure those that need to fix something are aware of it,  
+
and can arrange for a respin. Once the issue has been fixed, and confirmed,  
+
change the red X to a green check mark with the build Id where is was verified,  
+
so those doing the promotion know its ready to go.  
+
  
If a smoke test does not pass but the build can still be  
+
If a smoke test does not pass but the build can still be promoted, use a green check mark (ok) icon ([[Image:Checkmark.gif]]) but then document in the comments bug numbers, how the smoke test fails, workarounds, or cautions about the build.  
promoted, use a green check mark (ok) icon ([[Image:Checkmark.gif]]) but then  
+
document in the comments bug numbers, how the smoke test fails, workarounds,  
+
or cautions about the build.
+
  
If a build can be promoted and no issues were found, simple use  
+
If a build can be promoted and no issues were found, simple use the green check mark and include the initials or names of who performed the test.  
the green check mark and include the initials or names of who performed the test.
+
  
Remember the significant column for promoting a build is the left-most  
+
Remember the significant column for promoting a build is the left-most project column. If some component within a project has not (or can not) be tested, the Project Lead should either make sure someone does the test, or make a judgment call on if the build (from their project's point of view) can be promoted or not. If the smoke test could not be performed, a note should be made in the comments section that it wasn't performed, why, and why that should prevent promotion.  
project column. If some component within a project has not (or can not)  
+
be tested, the Project Lead should either make sure someone does the test,  
+
or make a judgment call on if the build (from their project's point of view)  
+
can be promoted or not. If the smoke test could not be performed, a note
+
should be made in the comments section that it wasn't performed, why, and  
+
why that should prevent promotion.
+
  
Keep in mind the threshold for promoting a build  
+
Keep in mind the threshold for promoting a build gets higher as we near a milestone or near a release.  
gets higher as we near a milestone or near a release.
+
 
+
{| border="3" cellpadding="5"
+
|+ This Week's Results
+
|Project ||Vote ||Initials Comments
+
  
 +
{| cellpadding="5" border="3"
 +
|+ This Week's Results
 +
|-
 +
| Project
 +
| Vote
 +
| Initials Comments
 
|-
 
|-
| Java EE
+
| Java EE  
| align="center" | [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|
+
| DMSR
 
|-
 
|-
|JSF
+
| JSF  
| align="center" | [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|
+
| rs
 
|-
 
|-
|Dali
+
| Dali  
| align="center" |[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|
+
| njh
 
|-
 
|-
|Server
+
| Server  
| align="center" |[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|
+
| EY
 
|-
 
|-
|Web Services, WSDL
+
| Web Services, WSDL  
| align="center" |[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]Web Services
+
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]Web Services(GP)
 +
[[Image:Checkmark.gif]]WSDL(GP)
  
[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]WSDL
+
[[Image:Checkmark.gif]]JAXWS (sc) Testsuite DNF [https://bugs.eclipse.org/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=329491 Bug#329491]
  
[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]JAXWS
 
 
|-
 
|-
| JSDT
+
| JSDT  
| align="center" | [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|
+
| cmj
 
|-
 
|-
|Source Editing
+
| Source Editing  
| align="center" |[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]XML + JSP
+
| [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]XML + JSP (ns)
 +
[[Image:Checkmark.gif]]XSD (GP)
  
[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]XSD
+
[[Image:Checkmark.gif]]XSL (nd - bvt only)
  
[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]XSL
 
 
|-
 
|-
|Release Engineering
+
| Release Engineering  
| align="center" |[[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
+
| align="center" | [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]  
|
+
| (dw) Some relatively minor versioning problems. Several recurring intermittent JUnit errors.
 
|}
 
|}
  
 +
<br>
  
 
  Smoke Test ok to promote vote = [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]
 
  Smoke Test ok to promote vote = [[Image:Checkmark.gif]]
Line 80: Line 67:
 
  Smoke Test Pending = [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
 
  Smoke Test Pending = [[Image:Questionmark.gif]]
  
 +
<br>
  
=====[[WTP Smoke Test Results | Back to the WTP Smoke Test Results Main Page]]=====
+
===== [[WTP Smoke Test Results|Back to the WTP Smoke Test Results Main Page]] =====

Latest revision as of 17:28, 17 December 2010

Smoke Test Promotion votes

Instructions:

Use a red X (fail) icon (Fail.gif) to signify that the build should not be promoted, that a respin is required. In that case, please provide bug number and be sure those that need to fix something are aware of it, and can arrange for a respin. Once the issue has been fixed, and confirmed, change the red X to a green check mark with the build Id where is was verified, so those doing the promotion know its ready to go.

If a smoke test does not pass but the build can still be promoted, use a green check mark (ok) icon (Checkmark.gif) but then document in the comments bug numbers, how the smoke test fails, workarounds, or cautions about the build.

If a build can be promoted and no issues were found, simple use the green check mark and include the initials or names of who performed the test.

Remember the significant column for promoting a build is the left-most project column. If some component within a project has not (or can not) be tested, the Project Lead should either make sure someone does the test, or make a judgment call on if the build (from their project's point of view) can be promoted or not. If the smoke test could not be performed, a note should be made in the comments section that it wasn't performed, why, and why that should prevent promotion.

Keep in mind the threshold for promoting a build gets higher as we near a milestone or near a release.

This Week's Results
Project Vote Initials Comments
Java EE Checkmark.gif DMSR
JSF Checkmark.gif rs
Dali Checkmark.gif njh
Server Checkmark.gif EY
Web Services, WSDL Checkmark.gif Checkmark.gifWeb Services(GP)

Checkmark.gifWSDL(GP)

Checkmark.gifJAXWS (sc) Testsuite DNF Bug#329491

JSDT Checkmark.gif cmj
Source Editing Checkmark.gif Checkmark.gifXML + JSP (ns)

Checkmark.gifXSD (GP)

Checkmark.gifXSL (nd - bvt only)

Release Engineering Checkmark.gif (dw) Some relatively minor versioning problems. Several recurring intermittent JUnit errors.


Smoke Test ok to promote vote = Checkmark.gif
Smoke Test do not promote vote = Fail.gif
Smoke Test Pending = Questionmark.gif


Back to the WTP Smoke Test Results Main Page