Jump to: navigation, search

Difference between revisions of "DTP PMC and Project Lead Meeting Minutes: January 15, 2007"

 
(10 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
←[[DTP PMC & Project Lead Meeting | Back to DTP PMC & Project Lead Meeting page]]
+
←[[DTP PMC and Project Lead Meeting | Back to DTP PMC and Project Lead Meeting page]]
 
==Attendees==
 
==Attendees==
 
+
*John Graham
 +
*Hung Hsi
 +
*Sheila Sholars
 +
*Der-Ping Chou
 +
*Rob Cernich
 +
*Linda Chan
 +
==Regrets==
 +
*Brian Payton
 
==Agenda==
 
==Agenda==
 
*Europa (DTP 1.5) planning:
 
*Europa (DTP 1.5) planning:
 +
**Eclipse Legal has set '''January 31''' as the deadline for submission of contribution requests for Europa. Therefore, inclusion of any external contributions or third party libraries '''must''' be in the Eclipse Legal pipeline on the 31st to be included in Europa.
 
**Our milestone dates are determined by the Europa schedule as posted in the [http://wiki.eclipse.org/index.php/Europa_Simultaneous_Release#Projects Milestones and Release Candidates] section of the Europa Wiki page. Note that DTP is in the "+1" category.
 
**Our milestone dates are determined by the Europa schedule as posted in the [http://wiki.eclipse.org/index.php/Europa_Simultaneous_Release#Projects Milestones and Release Candidates] section of the Europa Wiki page. Note that DTP is in the "+1" category.
**By the Europa schedule, the next DTP 1.5 milestone will be on February 16 (M5). There are a number of items, in addition to regular enhancement and bug fixes, that we should seriously consider for this milestone:
+
**By the Europa schedule, the next DTP 1.5 milestone will be on '''February 16 (M5)'''. There are a number of items, in addition to regular enhancement and bug fixes, that we should seriously consider for this milestone:
 
***Specify the VM version requirements for each plug-in (see item 8 in "Must Do" section of Europa Wiki page)
 
***Specify the VM version requirements for each plug-in (see item 8 in "Must Do" section of Europa Wiki page)
 
***Compress the DTP build using "pack 200" (see item 2 in "Must Do" section of Europa Wiki page). This will be done as part of the DTP build process, so only further testing is required by the team.
 
***Compress the DTP build using "pack 200" (see item 2 in "Must Do" section of Europa Wiki page). This will be done as part of the DTP build process, so only further testing is required by the team.
 
***Jar DTP plug-ins: In DTP 1.0, about half of the plug-ins were in directory format. Europa will look for us to reduce this number significantly, if not completely. We should start jarring as many plug-ins as possible, with the aim of being complete by M6 (March 30).
 
***Jar DTP plug-ins: In DTP 1.0, about half of the plug-ins were in directory format. Europa will look for us to reduce this number significantly, if not completely. We should start jarring as many plug-ins as possible, with the aim of being complete by M6 (March 30).
 +
**The PMC intends to have the high-level project plan posted by the end of January. I (John) propose that each project have their detailed 1.5 plans posted by the M5 (Feb. 16) Europa date. These detailed plans should include planned enhancements, major bug fixes, and as additional information about work projected for 1.5 as possible.
 
**Build environment
 
**Build environment
 
***The PMC has been discussing the build environment and set of supported configurations
 
***The PMC has been discussing the build environment and set of supported configurations
***We would to preserve the ability to run DTP 1.5 in Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2 and GEF 3.2 on a 1.4 VM if possible. But the offical environment for Europa is Eclipse 3.3, EMF 3.3 and GEF 3.3 on a 1.5 VM.
+
***We would to preserve the ability to run DTP 1.5 in Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2 and GEF 3.2 on a 1.4 VM if possible. But the offical environment for Europa is Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3 and GEF 3.3 on a 1.5 VM.
 
***We therefore propose that DTP 1.5 be built on Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2 and GEF 3.2 with a 1.4 but tested primarily on Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3 and GEF 3.3 with a 1.5 VM. To check compatiblity, test builds against Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3, GEF 3.3 on a 1.5 VM will be run to ensure that the code compiles in this environment, but '''all''' DTP 1.5 posted builds (nightly, milestone, rc and release) will be built on the Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2, GEF 3.2 and 1.4 VM stack.
 
***We therefore propose that DTP 1.5 be built on Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2 and GEF 3.2 with a 1.4 but tested primarily on Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3 and GEF 3.3 with a 1.5 VM. To check compatiblity, test builds against Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3, GEF 3.3 on a 1.5 VM will be run to ensure that the code compiles in this environment, but '''all''' DTP 1.5 posted builds (nightly, milestone, rc and release) will be built on the Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2, GEF 3.2 and 1.4 VM stack.
 
***Obviously this implies that any EMF model generation be done on EMF 2.2.
 
***Obviously this implies that any EMF model generation be done on EMF 2.2.
Line 18: Line 27:
  
 
==Minutes==
 
==Minutes==
 
+
*Discussion of Europa plan per agenda. The team agree with the planning dates.
 +
*Need to keep in mind that adopters need a ramp-down toward each milestone, so they can start testing before their deadlines too.
 +
*Discussion of DTP 1.5M5 work items:
 +
***VM levels: good idea to add for this milestone
 +
***Pack 200: If possible. Note that Pack 200 applies only for update site, not zipped downloads.
 +
***Jarring plug-ins: We should start during M5.
 +
*Discussion of build environment: Team agrees with the proposal in the agenda, reserving the right to drop Eclipse 3.2.x support if it becomes too difficult later. Given the Europa API freeze on 3/30, if we can handle both until then, we'll probably be fine for Europa.
 +
*Project retrospective: Collected retrospective will be circulated this week on dtp-dev/dtp-pmc. We can discuss on those mailing lists and the PMC can take under advisement any changes required.
 +
*Administrative note: Not team meeting next week, due to travel and Eclipse Council meetings
 
==Action Items==
 
==Action Items==
 +
*'''John:''' Restart nightly builds from DTP head based on agreed enviroment
 +
*'''John:''' Post retrospective comments to dtp-dev/dtp-pmc by end of this week
 +
*'''PMC:''' Publish high-level plan for DTP 1.5 by end of January
 +
*'''Project Leads:''' Publish detailed project plans by Feb 16

Latest revision as of 12:23, 6 July 2007

Back to DTP PMC and Project Lead Meeting page

Attendees

  • John Graham
  • Hung Hsi
  • Sheila Sholars
  • Der-Ping Chou
  • Rob Cernich
  • Linda Chan

Regrets

  • Brian Payton

Agenda

  • Europa (DTP 1.5) planning:
    • Eclipse Legal has set January 31 as the deadline for submission of contribution requests for Europa. Therefore, inclusion of any external contributions or third party libraries must be in the Eclipse Legal pipeline on the 31st to be included in Europa.
    • Our milestone dates are determined by the Europa schedule as posted in the Milestones and Release Candidates section of the Europa Wiki page. Note that DTP is in the "+1" category.
    • By the Europa schedule, the next DTP 1.5 milestone will be on February 16 (M5). There are a number of items, in addition to regular enhancement and bug fixes, that we should seriously consider for this milestone:
      • Specify the VM version requirements for each plug-in (see item 8 in "Must Do" section of Europa Wiki page)
      • Compress the DTP build using "pack 200" (see item 2 in "Must Do" section of Europa Wiki page). This will be done as part of the DTP build process, so only further testing is required by the team.
      • Jar DTP plug-ins: In DTP 1.0, about half of the plug-ins were in directory format. Europa will look for us to reduce this number significantly, if not completely. We should start jarring as many plug-ins as possible, with the aim of being complete by M6 (March 30).
    • The PMC intends to have the high-level project plan posted by the end of January. I (John) propose that each project have their detailed 1.5 plans posted by the M5 (Feb. 16) Europa date. These detailed plans should include planned enhancements, major bug fixes, and as additional information about work projected for 1.5 as possible.
    • Build environment
      • The PMC has been discussing the build environment and set of supported configurations
      • We would to preserve the ability to run DTP 1.5 in Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2 and GEF 3.2 on a 1.4 VM if possible. But the offical environment for Europa is Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3 and GEF 3.3 on a 1.5 VM.
      • We therefore propose that DTP 1.5 be built on Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2 and GEF 3.2 with a 1.4 but tested primarily on Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3 and GEF 3.3 with a 1.5 VM. To check compatiblity, test builds against Eclipse 3.3, EMF 2.3, GEF 3.3 on a 1.5 VM will be run to ensure that the code compiles in this environment, but all DTP 1.5 posted builds (nightly, milestone, rc and release) will be built on the Eclipse 3.2.x, EMF 2.2, GEF 3.2 and 1.4 VM stack.
      • Obviously this implies that any EMF model generation be done on EMF 2.2.
    • We are being encouraged to move to the standard PDE build system for Europa. Whatever we decide, our build procedure needs to be clearly documented as part of Europa [optional] requirements (item 3,4 in "Should Do" category of Europa Wiki page). We need to find staffing to support this.
  • Individual project status

Minutes

  • Discussion of Europa plan per agenda. The team agree with the planning dates.
  • Need to keep in mind that adopters need a ramp-down toward each milestone, so they can start testing before their deadlines too.
  • Discussion of DTP 1.5M5 work items:
      • VM levels: good idea to add for this milestone
      • Pack 200: If possible. Note that Pack 200 applies only for update site, not zipped downloads.
      • Jarring plug-ins: We should start during M5.
  • Discussion of build environment: Team agrees with the proposal in the agenda, reserving the right to drop Eclipse 3.2.x support if it becomes too difficult later. Given the Europa API freeze on 3/30, if we can handle both until then, we'll probably be fine for Europa.
  • Project retrospective: Collected retrospective will be circulated this week on dtp-dev/dtp-pmc. We can discuss on those mailing lists and the PMC can take under advisement any changes required.
  • Administrative note: Not team meeting next week, due to travel and Eclipse Council meetings

Action Items

  • John: Restart nightly builds from DTP head based on agreed enviroment
  • John: Post retrospective comments to dtp-dev/dtp-pmc by end of this week
  • PMC: Publish high-level plan for DTP 1.5 by end of January
  • Project Leads: Publish detailed project plans by Feb 16